C.U.N.Y. Digital Insights
The Art of Non-Profit Storytelling: A Guide to Creating Connection
Facts tell, but stories sell. This guide will teach you how to find and share the powerful human stories that will inspire your community and fuel your fundraising.
What is the single most powerful tool a non-profit has? It is not your database, your website, or your fundraising plan. It is your stories. Non-profit storytelling is the art of sharing the human impact of your work in a way that creates a deep, emotional connection with your audience. It is what turns a casual observer into a passionate supporter. It is the thread that connects all of your non-profit marketing and fundraising efforts.
People are wired for stories. A list of statistics about homelessness is easy to forget. But the story of one person who found a safe place to sleep because of your shelter is something people remember. It is what they will share with their friends. It is what will inspire them to give. This guide will show you how to master the art of storytelling. We will teach you how to find the powerful stories that already exist in your organization, how to craft them in a simple and compelling way, and how to share them with the world.
Why Stories Work: The Science of Connection
When we hear a list of facts, only the language parts of our brain light up. But when we hear a story, our brains react as if we are experiencing the events ourselves. The sensory parts of our brain activate. We feel the character’s hopes and fears. This creates empathy, a powerful emotion that is a key driver of charitable giving. A good story does not just inform your audience; it transports them. It makes them a participant in your mission.
Step 1: Find Your Stories
Your non-profit is a treasure chest of amazing stories. You just need to know where to look. The best stories are everywhere, but they often go untold. Make it a habit to actively look for and collect them.
Talk to Your Frontline Staff
Your program staff—the people who are doing the work on the ground every day—are your best source of stories. They see the impact of your work firsthand. Schedule regular, informal check-ins with them. Ask them simple questions like, “Who did you help this week?” or “Have you seen any amazing transformations lately?” Create a simple way for them to share stories with you, like a dedicated email address or a simple online form.
Talk to the People You Serve
The most powerful stories come directly from the people whose lives you have changed. This requires a process built on trust and respect, which we will discuss in our section on ethical storytelling. When done right, allowing someone to share their own story in their own words is incredibly powerful for them and for your audience.
Talk to Your Volunteers and Donors
Why do your volunteers give their time? Why did your donors make their first gift? The answers to these questions are stories. Sharing a donor’s personal connection to your cause can be very inspiring to other potential supporters. It provides powerful social proof.
Step 2: The 4 Key Elements of a Great Story
Every great story, from a Hollywood movie to a fundraising email, has a few key ingredients. When you are crafting your stories, make sure you have these four elements.
The 4 Elements of a Compelling Non-Profit Story
- 1. A Relatable Hero: Your story needs a main character that your audience can root for. This should be a specific person, not a group of people. Give them a name and share a few details about their life. The hero is the person you helped.
- 2. A Challenge to Overcome: What problem was your hero facing? Describe the struggle. This is what creates the emotional tension in the story.
- 3. The Solution (Your Impact): How did your organization help the hero overcome the challenge? This is where you show your work in action. Your non-profit is the guide that helps the hero succeed.
- 4. A Vision of a Better Future: What is the hero’s life like now? Show the “after.” This is the happy ending that your donors’ support makes possible.
Step 3: Tell Your Story Everywhere
Once you have a great story, you need to share it. Different channels require different ways of telling the same story. You can and should repurpose your best stories across all of your platforms.
On Your Website
Your website is the perfect place for long-form storytelling. Create a “Stories of Impact” section on your website. Here, you can write detailed blog posts with high-quality photos. You can also embed longer videos. Your website is where you can really dive deep and show the full picture. Your homepage should always feature a short, powerful story to immediately grab visitors’ attention.
In Your Emails
Email is a very personal channel, which makes it perfect for storytelling. A fundraising email should be built around a single, powerful story. Keep the text relatively short and scannable. Use a compelling photo to draw the reader in. The goal of the email is to create an emotional connection that leads the reader to click the “Donate Now” button. Our guide to email marketing has more tips on this.
On Social Media
Social media requires short, visual, and attention-grabbing stories. A powerful photo with a one-sentence caption can be a story. A short, 60-second video of someone sharing their experience is a story. Use platforms like Instagram and Facebook to share the emotional, in-the-moment stories of your work. Always include a link back to your website where people can learn more or make a gift.
Step 4: The Importance of Ethical Storytelling
When you are telling the stories of the people you serve, you have a huge responsibility. Ethical storytelling is about sharing these stories with dignity, respect, and honesty. It is about empowering the people in your stories, not exploiting them.
The Rules of Ethical Storytelling
Get Informed Consent: Always get full, written permission from the person whose story you are telling. Explain exactly how and where their story and photo will be used. Make sure they understand they can say no without any negative consequences.
Put the Person First: The story belongs to them, not to you. Let them tell it in their own words as much as possible. Review the final version with them before you publish it to make sure they are comfortable.
Focus on Strengths, Not Stereotypes: Tell stories that show the resilience, strength, and humanity of the people you serve. Avoid language that creates pity or reinforces negative stereotypes.
Step 5: Build a Story Bank
You should always be collecting stories. A “story bank” is a simple system for saving and organizing the stories you gather so they are ready to use when you need them. This can be as simple as a folder on a shared drive or a spreadsheet.
For each story, you should save:
- The person’s name and contact information.
- The written story.
- Any photos or videos.
- A signed consent form.
- A few keywords or tags to make the story easy to find (e.g., “housing,” “youth program”).
A well-organized story bank means you will never be scrambling for a powerful story for your next newsletter or fundraising appeal.
Your mission has a human heart. Storytelling is how you let the world see it.
Conclusion: Make Storytelling Part of Your Culture
Great storytelling is not just a job for the marketing department. It should be a part of your entire organization’s culture. Encourage everyone, from your program staff to your board members, to always be on the lookout for the powerful stories of impact that happen every day. When you make storytelling a central part of how you talk about your work, you do more than just raise money. You build a deep and lasting bond with your community. You remind people that behind all the data and the programs, there are real people whose lives are better because of your work and their support.
Your Questions, Answered
Common questions about non-profit storytelling.
Ready to Tell Your Non-Profit’s Story?
A great story can transform your fundraising and build a powerful connection with your community. We can help you find and craft the stories that will inspire action. Schedule a free consultation to get started.
Start a Conversation
